Last week I was asked by the New York Times to submit a draft of an Op-Ed piece on The Politics of Promotion. Needless to say, I was honored and worked diligently for two and a half days to complete an article I thought worthy of submission.
In my quest for perfection, I reached out to a couple of trusted friends and colleagues for feedback. After all, you can only read and re-read your own writing so many times before you lose sight of the significance.
What I noticed first of all is that though I asked for feedback, what I really wanted was validation. Because when I got the feedback, I was not ready to hear it. I said to myself, “Can’t you just tell me it’s terrific?” My need for approval put up a wall to hearing constructive criticism that would eventually improve the strength of my thesis.
Once I let my defensive wall down, I listened intently to the feedback. Some of it, I dismissed immediately. But some comments were insightful and resulted in the realization that I spend too much of my time in my own space; women’s advancement issues. So much of my time, energy, and passion is focused on this topic that I don’t recognize that not everyone is aware of the same issues and information. For instance, many people (probably most of the population for that matter) have no idea what second generation gender bias is. Most people don’t have a clue that there is a business case for having more women in leadership positions in business.
It took feedback from people outside of my space to help me realize that when speaking to a broader audience I need to educate and clarify.
The point I want to make in this blog is that we often get so caught up in our “stuff” that we assume everyone thinks and behaves as we do. When we have a network of like-minded colleagues and clients with whom we share information, we can lose sight of what other people know outside our immediate circle. It helps to have a diverse network to give you different points of view and of course, valuable feedback.
Constructive feedback is a gift. It allows you to expand your knowledge, your communication, and your influence. The most valuable feedback requires openness and vulnerability of the giver and the receiver.
Constructive feedback has also helped me to expand my knowledge and even helped me raise money! I agree that it requires a level of courage and vulnerability that can be daunting. One place I’ve learned to seek honest feedback is from my board members. One board member often sends me emails after calls with our investors or potential investors with notes on how I presented and tips on better ways of presenting the company. They are sometimes painful to read, but I am so grateful to have his feedback because I know it has made me a better CEO (I run a language teaching company for kids, Little Pim).
Bonnie Marcus, M.Ed, CEC
http://www.WomensSuccessCoaching.com
Forbes Top 100 Website for Professional Women
203 529 3202 (office)
774 563 8176 (cell)